By far the most eyebrow-raising story of the week came by way of Maine, where a psychic helping on a missing person cold case located a body, but the remains turned out to be someone else.

For the past few years, the family of Kimberly Moreau has been working with Laurencia Bourget in the hopes that her gift could provide them with some answers to the teen’s 1986 disappearance. Remarkably, the psychic recently contacted her father with the overwhelming sense that they needed to search behind an abandoned bowling alley in their community.

When they looked in the location, they were stunned to find a skeleton, though an examination by law enforcement determined that the remains were that of a man and not Kimberly.